Announcements

    Drinks

      US government shutdown reflects deepening political polarisation in credit-negative development
      WEDNESDAY, 01/10/2025 - Scope Ratings GmbH
      Download PDF

      US government shutdown reflects deepening political polarisation in credit-negative development

      The latest government shutdown in the United States occurred as a result of policy disagreements between Republicans and Democrats on issues such as healthcare, but it reflects the country’s deepening political polarisation.

      By Eiko Sievert, Sovereign and Public Sector

      The administration’s increasingly unconventional policy approach has placed pressure on the long-standing checks and balances of the US governance system and are seen as credit negative for the US sovereign rating outlook (AA/Negative).

      In recent months, questions about the independence and credibility of key institutions have intensified. The Federal Reserve has faced growing political scrutiny, culminating in the attempted dismissal of Governor Lisa Cook, and testing the boundaries of presidential authority with respect to oversight of independent institutions. Similarly, legal professionals and firms perceived as adversarial to President Trump’s policy objectives have been subjected to public pressure, while concerns have also emerged around the impartiality of economic data following the dismissal of Erika McEntarfer, the former Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

      Broader challenges have also arisen from heightened criticism of academic institutions and the press which risk eroding public trust in the country’s system of checks and balances. Of additional concern is the increasing normalisation of military deployments in American cities, with the stated aim of preserving public order. Civil authority could particularly be undermined when such deployments become more frequent even without state governors’ consent.

      Overall, this deterioration in governance standards is set to further increase political polarisation in the years ahead. The deeper these political divisions become, the greater the risk that key policy compromises may not be reached by the relevant deadline.

      This also applies to future debt-ceiling standoffs, particularly if the Republican party were to lose control of the House and/or Senate after the 2026 midterm election. Despite a USD 5 trillion increase in the debt ceiling agreed as part of the ‘Big Beautiful Bill’, a further increase will likely be needed by 2028 given the weak fiscal outlook. We expect deficits of around 6% of GDP and an increase in national debt to 127% of GDP in the next five years.

      Our baseline remains that the risk of a technical default by the U.S. due to political disputes is not very likely, but the risk continues to increase and would have a significant impact if it occurred.
       

      Related news

      Show all
      Ukrainian debt sustainability challenges remain heightened as new IMF programme talks accelerate

      29/9/2025 Research

      Ukrainian debt sustainability challenges remain heightened as ...

      Scope has completed a monitoring review for the Land of Baden-Württemberg

      26/9/2025 Monitoring note

      Scope has completed a monitoring review for the Land of ...

      Scope affirms Croatia’s credit ratings at A- and revises the Outlook to Positive

      26/9/2025 Rating announcement

      Scope affirms Croatia’s credit ratings at A- and revises the ...

      Scope affirms France’s AA- credit rating and revises the Outlook to Negative

      26/9/2025 Rating announcement

      Scope affirms France’s AA- credit rating and revises the ...

      Scope has completed a monitoring review for the city of Trondheim

      26/9/2025 Monitoring note

      Scope has completed a monitoring review for the city of Trondheim